Acer's Googlebook 14, reviewed twice: the same laptop is excellent hardware and unfinished software
Two October reviews of the $899 Acer Googlebook 14 agree on the OLED screen and disagree on whether the Googlebook OS is ready. Here is where they split.
- Section
- Gadgets
- Published
- Read
- 4 min
- Sources
- 2
Put two reviewers in front of the same laptop and you usually get the same verdict in different words. The Acer Googlebook 14 is a rarer case. Stuart Andrews at ITPro and Adam Doud at SlashGear handled nearly identical machines in October, praised the same hardware, and ended up in different places on the one question that matters for a first-generation platform: is the software ready to buy?
The machine they agree on
The Googlebook 14 is a 14-inch 2-in-1 with a 360-degree hinge, and SlashGear calls it the only Googlebook that works as a tablet. Both reviews describe a 120Hz OLED touchscreen: 2880 x 1800 in ITPro’s listing, 500 nits peak brightness in SlashGear’s. The body is aluminium and magnesium, with a bit of deck flex noted by SlashGear, and the battery is 71 Wh.
Prices differ by region and configuration. SlashGear’s headline price is “$899 and up (way up).” ITPro cites £999 including VAT for the Core Ultra 5 325 model and £1,099 for the Core Ultra 7 355 it tested, and notes a US retail listing at $899 for a Core Ultra 5, 16GB, 512GB configuration. Doud tested the Core Ultra 5; Andrews the Core Ultra 7.
Andrews put the hardware plainly: “Acer’s hardware is fantastic, and a great way to trial Googlebooks without investing too much.” Neither review lists the screen among its complaints.
Where the reviews part
Battery is the first split, and it is partly a matter of workload. ITPro’s video rundown test lasted 14 hours and nine minutes, which the reviewer called “not a terrible result,” and over a week of working the laptop usually reached the end of the day without a recharge, though evening work sometimes needed one. SlashGear’s author “barely squeaked by” eight hours in a typical workday and called that underwhelming. A video loop is kind to batteries; a day of phones, hotspots and app casting is not. The two numbers do not contradict each other so much as measure different things.
The larger split is stability. Doud lists problems that are hard to wave away:
- the screen periodically goes white and redraws;
- the virtual keyboard sometimes sticks to the screen;
- everything once registered as a right-click until a reboot, which also broke Instant Hotspot;
- the fingerprint scanner worked about 70% of the time;
- app casting from a phone was very laggy at first and improved over about a week.
His conclusion is blunt: the launch feels rushed, and he “can’t recommend it as a product a consumer should purchase as-is.” Andrews reports no comparable list of glitches. His reservations are about apps.
The app problem
On what the machine can and cannot run, the two reviews line up closely, which is useful because it is where buyers get caught. Googlebook OS runs Android apps, progressive web apps and Google Drive natively. It can also stream apps from a paired phone, provided both are on the same Wi-Fi network. It cannot run Windows software. ITPro adds that full-featured Adobe and Microsoft apps are not there; the Android versions are reduced-function mobile apps. SlashGear found Slack usable as a progressive web app but not as a native one.
Andrews: “App support is still Google’s biggest issue.” He adds that “it works best if you’re already invested in Android, cloud-native apps, and the wider Google ecosystem,” and that for some enterprises the gap “is going to be a barrier.”
Gemini and the phone link
Both reviews spend time on the features Google wants to sell. ITPro says Gemini is embedded more deeply than it was on Chromebook Plus machines, with summary and content tools never more than a tap away, and praises a voice dictation tool called Rambler that removes filler words and handles self-corrections. It also likes handing a task from phone to laptop and picking up a browser page where you left off, though it would be better if it worked every time with every app.
SlashGear is less generous. Continue On works with some Google apps, such as Docs, and a few third-party apps, but not Threads or YouTube. The Magic Cursor, which sends selected screen content to Gemini, works; the custom AI widgets built from natural language were, in Doud’s experience, mostly unhelpful. His summary is that apart from a few features not all apps support, there is little here a high-end Chromebook would not also offer.
What the split tells a buyer
Reading the two together suggests a way to sort buyers:
- Already deep in Android and Google Workspace: the hardware is good, and Andrews’s view applies. A trial is reasonable at the lower price.
- Dependent on Windows or full Adobe and Office tools: both reviews point away from this laptop today.
- Wanting a polished consumer product now: Doud’s list of glitches is the cautionary note, and one reviewer’s experience may not match yours.
The shared message is that Acer did its part. The open question belongs to Google: whether the next few software updates close the distance between a laptop worth owning and a platform worth betting on. Until then, the price is paying for the screen and the promise.
Sources
More in Gadgets
-
Samsung and Google's Android XR glasses open for preorder from $395, with no display and a phone-list catch
The display-free Android XR glasses from Samsung and Google cost $395 to $489 and ship Dec. 10 in the US and South Korea. Check your phone against the list first.
-
Asus cuts the ExpertBook A7's price by $400 with less RAM and a 26-hour battery claim to check
Asus's 14-inch ExpertBook A7 now comes in cheaper 8GB and 12GB versions. The savings are real; the 26-hour battery claim measured 17 hours in one test.
-
Fitbit Edge at $179.99: one reviewer calls it restraint, another calls it undercooked
Two October reviews of Google's Fitbit Edge agree on the seven-day battery and split over whether leaving out NFC, a speaker and workout depth is a feature or a flaw.